Air Today . . . Gone Tomorrow Article
Sierra Club releases
report on environmental response to 9/11
By Albert Amateau and Josh Rogers,
Downtown Express, Volume 17 Issue 13 | August 20-26, 2004
The Sierra Club issued a report on
Wednesday charging that federal agencies misinformed Downtown residents and businesses
about the hazards of air pollution from the World Trade Center attack and failed to take
proper action to prevent exposure to toxic vapors and airborne particles.
The 200-page report that the environmental
group issued at an Aug. 18 news conference on the steps of City Hall also contends that
the Bush administration plans to include some of the procedures that failed to protect
Lower Manhattan on Sept. 11, 2001 in its new national policy on future emergencies.
"Weve learned a lot about these
failures already but the new thing in the report is that federal procedures on future
disasters will be the same as before," said Congressmember Jerrold Nadler, a
long-time critic of government environmental response to the attack who attended the
Sierra Club conference. "The Environmental Protection Agency, FEMA and OSHA
[Occupational Safety and Health Administration] have learned nothing."
Nadler said he believed people in Lower
Manhattan and Downtown Brooklyn were being "poisoned" to this day, but when
asked, he said he did not favor evacuating the areas. He repeated his call to have the
E.P.A. begin a more stringent testing and cleanup program.
The Sierra Club contends that hundreds of
people have had health problems attributable to pollution from the attack and that E.P.A.
failed to find toxic hazards "because it did not look for them." The club also
contends that the White House Council on Environmental Quality provided misleading data on
the 9/11 asbestos hazard in a letter to Senators Hillary Clinton of New York and Joseph
Lieberman of Connecticut.
The report also recalled an E.P.A.
Inspector General report in August of last year that the White House environmental quality
council blocked health risk information that the E.P.A. wanted to release to the public
after the 9/11 attack.
"Indeed even after the E.P.A.
launched an indoor clean-up program, it continued to assure residents that it was not
really needed," the report says.
During the clean-up at ground zero, OSHA
refused to enforce federal worker safety requirements, claiming it did not have authority
in national emergencies. After the emergency period passed, OSHA still refused to enforce
the rules even after ground zero safety was compromised, the report says.
Despite public warnings about the
importance of wearing gas masks at the W.T.C. site, many workers were often seen without
masks while the recovery and cleanup operation was underway.
For the future, the Bush administration is
eliminating OSHAs enforcement role at national emergency sites, the report says.
Under a new National Emergency Management Plan, OSHA will provide only technical
assistance.
The administration is also contemplating
emergency clean-up standards that are weaker than standards for Superfund clean-up sites,
the report says.
The Sierra Club recommends a new clean-up
of W.T.C. dust for residential and commercial buildings, including firehouses, emergency
vehicles and equipment. Long-term medical monitoring and treatment is also needed.
Moreover, the group wants the government to publicly censure the White House environmental
quality council official who toned down the health warnings that E.P.A. wanted to issue
after the attack.
A new E.P.A. panel, which was formed at
the insistence of Sen. Clinton and which includes independent experts, is considering a
plan to test buildings over a larger geographic area.
The Sierra report also says government
should work with communities, institutions and environmental advocates to develop national
emergency policies promoting truthfulness about health hazards. The Sierra Club also wants
the government to maintain emergency clean-up standards and to drop plans to eliminate
enforcement of safety standards for emergency workers.
All rights reserved. Downtown Express
http//www.downtownexpress.com/de_67/sierraclubreleasesreport.html
FAIR USE NOTICE
This article contains copyrighted material, the use of which has not always been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I am making such material available in my
efforts to advance understanding of democracy, economic, environmental, human rights,
political, scientific, and social justice issues, among others. I believe this constitutes
a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US
Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107,
the material in this article is distributed without profit for research and educational
purposes. Take me back to learn more |