Air Today . . . Gone Tomorrow Article|
Secrecy, Lies And
Cronkite, Yankton Daily Press & Dakotan, April 1, 2004
The initial refusal of President Bush to let his national-security adviser appear under
oath before the 9/11 Commission might have been in keeping with a principle followed by
other presidents -- the principle being, according to Bush, that calling his advisers to
testify under oath is a congressional encroachment on the executive branch's turf. (Never
mind that this commission is not a congressional body, but one he created and whose
members he handpicked.) But standing on that principle has proved to be politically
damaging, in part because this administration -- the most secretive since Richard Nixon's
-- already suffers from a deepening credibility problem. It all brings to mind something
I've wondered about for some time Are secrecy and credibility natural enemies?
When you stop to think about it, you keep secrets from people when you don't want them to
know the truth. Secrets, even when legitimate and necessary, as in genuine
national-security cases, are what you might call passive lies.
Take the recent flap over Richard Foster, the Medicare official whose boss threatened to
fire him if he revealed to Congress that the prescription-drug bill would be a lot more
expensive than the administration claimed. The White House tried to pass it all off as the
excessive and unauthorized action of Foster's supervisor (who shortly after the threatened
firing left the government).
Maybe. But the point is that the administration had the newer, higher numbers, and
Congress had been misled. This was a clear case of secrecy being used to protect a lie. I
can't help but wonder how many other faulty estimates by this administration have actually
been misinformation explained as error.
The Foster story followed by only a few weeks the case of the U.S. Park police chief who
got the ax for telling a congressional staffer -- and The Washington Post -- that budget
cuts planned for her department would impair its ability to perform its duties. Chief
Teresa Chambers since has accepted forced retirement from government service.
Isolated incidents? Not really. Looking back at the past three years reveals a pattern of
secrecy and of dishonesty in the service of secrecy. Some New Yorkers felt they had been
lied to following the horrific collapse of the World Trade Center towers. Proposed
warnings by the Environmental Protection Agency -- that the air quality near ground zero
might pose health hazards -- were watered down or deleted by the White House and replaced
with the reassuring message that the air was safe to breathe.
The EPA's own inspector general said later that the agency did not have sufficient data to
claim the air was safe. However, the reassurance was in keeping with the president's
defiant back-to-work/business-as-usual theme to demonstrate the nation's strength and
resilience. It also was an early example of a Bush administration reflex described by one
physicist as "never let science get in the way of policy."
In April of 2002, the EPA had prepared a nationwide warning about a brand of asbestos
called Zonolite, which contained a form of the substance far more lethally dangerous than
ordinary asbestos. However, reportedly at the last minute, the White House stopped the
warning. Why? The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, which broke the story, noted that the Bush
administration at the time was pushing legislation limiting the asbestos manufacturer's
liability. Whatever the reason, such silence by an agency charged with protecting our
health is a silent lie in my book.
One sometimes gets the impression that this administration believes that how it runs the
government is its business and no one else's. It is certainly not the business of
Congress. And if it's not the business of the people's representatives, it's certainly no
business of yours or mine.
But this is a dangerous condition for any representative democracy to find itself in. The
tight control of information, as well as the dissemination of misleading information and
outright falsehoods, conjures up a disturbing image of a very different kind of society.
Democracies are not well-run nor long-preserved with secrecy and lies.
Write to Walter Cronkite c/o King Features Syndicate, 888 Seventh Ave., New York, NY
10019, or e-mail him at firstname.lastname@example.org.
FAIR USE NOTICE
This article contains copyrighted material, the use of which has not always been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I am making such material
available in my efforts to advance understanding of democracy, economic,
environmental, human rights, political, scientific, and social justice issues,
among others. I believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted
material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance
with Title 17 U.S.C. Section
107, the material in this article is distributed without profit for research
and educational purposes.
Take me back to learn more