|
Animals and Religion
— Judaism's Perspective
Although various Christian clergy have come out
with their individual beliefs attesting to the holiness or
redeemable nature of animals, most adhere to the belief that
scripture does not offer a definitive answer.
Yet, in
Judaism, issues related to animal kindness and to the questions of whether animals have souls and
whether our beloved companion animals go to heaven are
clearly addressed.
CHAI, an organization in Israel, is striving to foster
empathy, respect, and responsibility toward all living
beings. They are inspiring and empowering people, Jewish,
Muslim, and Christian, to recognize the interconnectedness
of all life and to make compassionate choices for the good
of all.
The following True-False quiz on
Judaism and Kindness to Animals comes from their
fabulous
Curriculum for Children Jewish Humane Education Kit.
Let's see how you do!
1. |
G-d made covenants with animals just as with
people. |
2. |
Only humans go to Heaven. |
3. |
Hunting for sport is permissible as long as
the animals have a "sporting chance." |
4. |
Rebecca was chosen to be Isaac's wife
because she gave water to some thirsty
camels. |
5. |
Rabbi Judah suffered from a toothache for
thirteen years because he ignored a calf's
plea for help, but his health was restored
when he prevented his daughter from killing
a family of weasels. |
6. |
Any animal that kills a human should be put
to death immediately. |
7. |
A person who was a spectator at gladiatorial
games was only condemned if the games
involved humans. |
8. |
A person who is noble, polite, sensible,
learned, and orthodox may be considered
righteous even though he or she is cruel to
animals. |
9. |
Noah was called righteous because he spent
an entire year caring for animals in the
Ark. |
10. |
Since humans are given dominion over the
animals, we can subordinate all their needs
to ours. |
11. |
When an animal is slaughtered for food, the
blood of the animal or bird is covered to
indicate that killing is a shameful act. |
12. |
Animal sacrifices are considered worthy
deeds. |
13. |
It is important to muzzle oxen when they are
threshing corn. |
14. |
It is forbidden to tie the legs of a beast
or of a bird in a manner that would cause
them pain. |
15. |
Although a blessing is said when new clothes
are worn, the blessing may not be said if
the clothes are made of fur or leather, for
you have killed to get them. |
16. |
There is a special blessing only for fruit,
vegetables, bread, and wine, but not for
meat dishes. |
17. |
Animals are to be fed and watered only after
humans have finished eating. |
18. |
Only humans are required to rest on the
Sabbath. Animals can work on the Sabbath as
long as it is for a non-Jew. |
19. |
The first diet of humans and animals was
vegetarian, and one day we will all be
vegetarians once again. |
20. |
You should help an animal in distress only
if you don't have to violate the Sabbath or
interrupt the carrying out of a commandment
do so. |
21 |
You are not permitted to wear leather shoes
on Yom Kipper because you can't ask for
compassion for yourself if you haven't shown
it to others. |
22. |
G-d chose Moses and David as leaders of
their people because of their compassion for
animals. |
|
Quiz Answers and Discussion
(from
CHAI Online)
1. G-d made covenants with animals just as with
people.
True
— Genesis 9:8-12; Hosea
2:18
2.
Only humans go to Heaven.
False
— Ecclesiastes
3:18-22
3. Hunting for sport is permissible as long as
the animals have a "sporting chance."
False
— In the Responsa
literature, hunting is deplored as wasteful,
unnecessarily cruel, and dangerous to human life.
"Based on the statement 'not to stand in the path of
sinners' (Psalms 1:1), the Talmud prohibited
association with hunters." (R. Schwartz, Judaism and
Vegetarianism)
4. Rebecca was chosen to be Isaac's wife
because she gave water to some thirsty
camels. True
— Genesis 24:11-20
5. Rabbi Judah suffered from a toothache for
thirteen years because he ignored a calf's
plea for help, but his health was restored
when he prevented his daughter from killing
a family of weasels.
True
— Psalms 145:9; Baba
Metzia 85a; Genesis Rabbah 33:3
6. Any animal that kills a human should be put
to death immediately.
False
— Like humans, animals
have responsibilities as well as rights (for
example, the right to Sabbath rest and the right to
protection from needless suffering). Animals that
kill people may be put to death only after due
consideration of all the circumstances, including
whether the death was accidental.
7. A person who was a spectator at gladiatorial
games was only condemned if the games
involved humans.
False
— "He who sits in a
stadium spills blood." Talmud. No distinction was
made between human victims and animal victims. (Avodah
Zarah 1)
8. A person who is noble, polite, sensible,
learned, and orthodox may be considered
righteous even though he or she is cruel to
animals. False
— "The righteous man
regardeth the life of his beast," or translated
literally "the righteous man knoweth the soul of his
beast." (Proverbs 12:10) "The man...who is careless
and indifferent about it (his animal), though he may
not be hard-hearted and cruel to it, yet inasmuch as
he regards it not, he is an unrighteous man; for the
righteous man regards the life, the desire and the
happiness of his beast....If I know that a man is
cruel to his beast, I ask no more questions about
him. He may be a noble man, or a rich man, or a
polite man, or a sensible man, or a learned man, or
an orthodox man, or a church man, or anything else,
it matters not; this I know, on the sacred word of a
wise king, that being cruel to his beast, he is a
wicked man." (Humphrey Primatt, Dissertation on the
Duty of Mercy and Sin of Cruelty to Brute Animals,
London T. Cadell, 1776, p. 208/9 and "Sefer Orhot
Tsadikim," Koenigsberg, H. Gruber, 1858, p. 17 as
quoted in "Tsa'ar Ba'ale Hayim, The Prevention of
Cruelty to Animals, Its Bases, Development and
Legislation in Hebrew Literature" by Noah J. Cohen,
Feldheim Publishers, N.Y., 1976).
9. Noah was called righteous because he spent
an entire year caring for animals in the
Ark. True
— According to several
interpretive sources, the word "righteous" is
applied to people who supply food to people or
animals in times of distress. Tan Huma BI, 31; Tan
Huma Noah 3.
10. Since humans are given dominion over the
animals, we can subordinate all their needs
to ours. False
— See answer to question
#8 above. As God is a good shepherd to humans, so
humans are to be good shepherds to animals. Ezekiel
34:1-6. Dominion means stewardship, not a license to
abuse. "There can be no doubt in the minds of every
thinking man that the concept of dominion as
expressed in the Torah...does not in any way imply
the rule of a haughty despot who tyrannically
governs his people and his servants for his own
personal selfish ends and with a stubborn heart.
Heaven forbid that such a repulsive form of
servitude be forever integrated (sealed) in the
world of the Lord, whose tender mercies are on all
His works and of whom it is said, 'He shall build a
world of kindness." Rabbi Yitzchak Hacohen Kook
(first rabbi of pre-state Israel), "The Vision of
Vegetarianism and Peace," edited and compiled by
"The Nazeer of Jerusalem," Rabbi David Hacohen, from
a lecture delivered by Joe Green entitled "Chalutzim
of the Messiah," p. 2, P.O. Box 64119, Highlands
North, Johannesburg, South Africa.
11. When an animal is slaughtered for food, the
blood of the animal or bird is covered to
indicate that killing is a shameful act.
True
— Leviticus 17:13; "The
removal of blood, which kashrut teaches, is one of
the most powerful means of making us constantly
aware of the concession and compromise which the
whole act of eating meat, in reality, is. Again, it
teaches us reverence for life." (Rabbi Samuel
Dresner, "Jewish Dietary Laws," p. 29); "The
covering of the blood of slaughtered beasts and
birds can be likened to a Divine Protest — The
eating of meat with all thy soul without any concept
of inner opposition was due to the low spiritual
state of man. To this the Torah retorted, 'Cover the
blood, hide thy shame and your moral weakness.' The
aforementioned deals with beasts and birds, which in
the majority of cases live in surroundings which are
situated far from man's domestic habitat. With
regard to the slaughter of domestic animals, that
is, those that live in close proximity to man, the
procedure is the opposite. The blood is not covered,
in order that your eyes shall behold the blood that
has been spilt and the blood shall cry out to you
from the face of the Earth at first with a still
small voice which in due course will penetrate the
ears of the most deaf and open the eyes of those who
are blind (to the message). And in that day, 'I
shall remove your stony heart and replace it with a
heart of flesh.' " Rabbi Yitzchak Hacohen Kook, "The
Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace," ibid.
12. Animal sacrifices are considered worthy
deeds. False
— Psalms 40:6 and 50:9-14;
Isaiah 1:11-15 and 66:3; Hosea 6:6 and 8:13; Micah
6:6-8.
13. It is important to muzzle oxen when they are
threshing corn.
False
— Deuteronomy 25:4: "At
the time of threshing, when the ox is surrounded by
the food that he enjoys so much, it should not be
prevented from satisfying its appetite." (Richard
Schwartz, "Judaism and Vegetarianism," p. 12). Rabbi
Samson Raphael Hirsch cites the Talmud (Choshen
Mishpat 338) as indicating that you may prevent an
animal from eating that which would harm it.
(Hirsch, "Horeb," p.293 as quoted in R. Schwartz,
ibid).
14. It is forbidden to tie the legs of a beast
or of a bird in a manner that would cause
them pain. True
— "Code of Jewish Law,"
Rabbi Solomon Gamzfried, Hebrew Publishing Company,
N.Y., 1961, book 4, chapter 191, p.84.
15. Although a blessing is said when new clothes
are worn, the blessing may not be said if
the clothes are made of fur or leather, for
you have killed to get them.
True
— Ganzfried, comp., "Code
of Jewish Law," Vol.2, p. 29 as quoted in Richard
Schwartz, op.cit., p.18. Similarly, leather shoes
may not be worn on Yom Kipper because it is not
proper to plead for compassion when one has not
shown it to other living creatures. (Joe Green, "The
Jewish Vegetarian Tradition," Johannesburg, South
Africa: Joe Green, 1969, p.15, based on the teaching
of the Ramah — as quoted in R. Schwartz, op.cit.,
pp. 17-18).
16. There is a special blessing only for fruit,
vegetables, bread, and wine, but not for
meat dishes. True
— R. Schwartz, op. cit.,
p.7.
17. Animals are to be fed and watered only after
humans have finished eating.
False
— Gitten 62a; based on
Deuteronomy (11:15); "And I will give grass in thy
fields for thy cattle, and thou shalt eat and be
satisfied." Food for cattle is provided before food
for humans. See R. Schwartz, op.cit., p.13.
18. Only humans are required to rest on the
Sabbath. Animals can work on the Sabbath as
long as it is for a non-Jew.
False
— Exodus 20:8-10 and
Exodus 23:12.
19. The first diet of humans and animals was
vegetarian, and one day we will all be
vegetarians once again.
True
— Genesis 1:29-30, Isaiah
11:6-9; Hosea 2:20. The famous Jewish Bible
commentator Rashi states the following: "God did not
permit Adam and his wife to kill a creature and to
eat its flesh. Only every green herb shall they all
eat together." (See R. Schwartz, op.cit., p.1.)
Rabbi Kook and Joseph Albo state that in the days of
the Messiah, people will again be vegetarians. (See
R. Schwartz, op. cit., pp.1-5.)
20. You should help an animal in distress only
if you don't have to violate the Sabbath or
interrupt the carrying out of a commandment
do so. False
— "The duty to feed an
animal first is so great that a person may interrupt
the performance of a rabbinic commandment in order
to ascertain that this has been done. For example, a
person may, after saying the benediction over bread,
not immediately eat the bread in order to inquire as
to whether the animals have been fed." (Orach Chayim
167:6; Berachot 40a as quoted in R. Schwartz, op.
cit., p.14.
On Yom Kippur eve, Rabbi Israel Salanter freed a
Christian neighbor's calf that had become lost and
tangled in the brush and led it home through many
fields and over many hills. His act of mercy
represented his prayers that Yom Kippur evening.
(S.T. Agnon, Days of Awe, Shocken, Jerusalem, 1939,
see R. Schwartz op. cit., p. 20). See also the story
of Rabbi Abramtzi, R. Schwartz, op. cit., p. 21.
21. You are not permitted to wear leather shoes
on Yom Kipper because you can't ask for
compassion for yourself if you haven't shown
it to others.
True
— See answer to #15.
22. G-d chose Moses and David as leaders of
their people because of their compassion for
animals. True
— Exodus Rabbah 2:2. Also,
Rebecca was chosen as Isaac's wife because of the
kindness she showed to animals (Genesis 24:11-20).
Jacob also demonstrated concern for animals (Genesis
33:12-14). See Richard Schwartz, op. cit., pp.18-19.
FAIR USE NOTICE
The articles on this page contain copyrighted material, the use of which has not always been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I am making such material available in my
efforts to advance understanding of human rights and social justice issues, among others. I believe this constitutes
a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US
Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107,
the material in this article is distributed without profit for research and educational
purposes. |
|